Neutral Validation and the Limits of Wire Fraud
The Peraire-Bueno brothers were acquitted on all charges after the court rejected the government’s wire-fraud theory.
On November 16, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on all charges. Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke found that the government had failed to prove a material misrepresentation required for wire fraud. The court granted judgment of acquittal on wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering, and directed the clerk to close the case.
Federal prosecutors had accused the brothers of fraud after they exploited a vulnerability in MEV-Boost relay software to capture value sought by competing trading bots. The prosecution’s “honest validator” theory sought to treat Ethereum validators as though they owed broad, unwritten duties to other participants in a permissionless network.
Coin Center filed an amicus brief challenging that theory. Our brief explained that “honest” validation has a specific technical meaning tied to a network’s mathematical consensus rules. That technical role does not create an open-ended legal duty to meet prosecutors’ expectations of fair play.
The court found insufficient evidence that the brothers’ interactions with Ethereum and the Ultrasound Relay conveyed the material misrepresentations alleged by the government. Registering with the relay did not establish the commitments the prosecution claimed, and technical descriptions of “honest” validation did not establish legally actionable representations. The acquittal is an important victory for clear limits on wire-fraud prosecutions involving open networks: the government could not substitute frustrated expectations or a system’s intended design for proof of material deception.