Sanctions and Autonomous Privacy Tools

The government cannot sanction immutable software that is neither a foreign person nor anyone’s property.

Coin Center v. Yellen

Coin Center and a group of ordinary privacy-seeking Americans challenged Treasury’s decision to sanction Tornado Cash’s immutable smart contracts. Those contracts are simply software deployed to the Ethereum blockchain: no person owns or controls them, and they cannot be altered or switched off. Coin Center argues that sanctions law authorizes the Treasury Department to block foreign persons and their property, not neutral software tools that Americans use for lawful privacy.

The sanctions prevented people from using Tornado Cash to receive a salary privately, support causes without exposing themselves to retaliation, and donate to organizations without revealing a complete financial history on a public blockchain. They also burdened Coin Center’s ability to accept private donations and protect the associational privacy of its supporters.

OFAC later removed the Tornado Cash smart contracts and website from its sanctions list, and the case is currently paused. The underlying principle remains important: the government should target identifiable wrongdoers and their property, not ban open-source tools that remain available to everyone. Clear limits on sanctions authority protect privacy, speech, and lawful use of decentralized networks.