Privacy in Exchange Records
The IRS should not use a John Doe summons to collect detailed financial histories without individualized suspicion.
James Harper challenged the IRS’s use of a John Doe summons to obtain identifying information and transaction records for broad groups of cryptocurrency exchange customers. Unlike a conventional investigation tied to a known taxpayer, a John Doe summons can sweep in people whose identities are unknown and against whom the government has no individualized suspicion.
Coin Center’s brief explained that blockchain records are unusually revealing. Once the government links a person’s identity to an address, it can trace years of public transactions and reconstruct a detailed financial and behavioral history. Demanding this information in bulk risks turning a targeted tax-enforcement tool into a general surveillance program.
The courts ultimately declined to grant Harper relief, but the issue remains urgent. Tax enforcement should be focused and proportionate, with meaningful judicial limits on collection. Cryptocurrency users do not surrender all privacy simply because they used an exchange, and the government should not obtain a searchable map of lawful financial activity without a particularized basis.